Otterbein’s has been making cookies since 1881. We’ve added a few new flavors since then, but we keep things simple. We use just a few high-quality ingredients in each cookie: no fillers, no artificial flavors, no preservatives. They’re made with natural ingredients and stay fresh for weeks—but once you taste them, they won’t last long. ORDER YOUR FAVORITES OR TRY ALL FIVE—available in attractive gift tins. We ship anywhere!
“I discovered your cookies at my local Shop Rite this year, and I think they are the best cookies in the world! My favorite are the Sugar and Chocolate Chip. They are actually better than homemade. I was afraid they were a one time thing on the shelf but I am so happy to see they are every week. I checked out your website and saw all the other comments, so I guess I’m not the only one who loves them so much. Keep baking and I’ll keep buying!!!!”